Skip to content
  • ISSUES
    • Understanding the Issues
    • Autonomy v Public Safety
    • Pressure and Coercion
    • Disability Concerns
    • Poverty Issues
    • Impact on the NHS
    • Palliative Care
    • Public Polling
    • Slippery Slope
    • Vague Definitions
    • Anorexia & Depression
    • Means of Death
    • Unsolved Problems
    • Suicide Prevention
    • Alternative Approach
  • Quotes
  • Latest
  • ISSUES
    • Understanding the Issues
    • Autonomy v Public Safety
    • Pressure and Coercion
    • Disability Concerns
    • Poverty Issues
    • Impact on the NHS
    • Palliative Care
    • Public Polling
    • Slippery Slope
    • Vague Definitions
    • Anorexia & Depression
    • Means of Death
    • Unsolved Problems
    • Suicide Prevention
    • Alternative Approach
  • Quotes
  • Latest
  • Home
  • ISSUES
    • Understanding the issues
    • Autonomy v Public Safety
    • Pressure and Coercion
    • Disability Concerns
    • Poverty Issues
    • Impact on the NHS
    • Palliative Care
    • Public Polling
    • Slippery Slope
    • Vague Definitions
    • Means of Death
    • Anorexia & Depression
    • Unsolved Problems
    • Suicide Prevention
    • Alternative Approach
  • Latest
  • Quotes
  • Contact
  • Join the Campaign
  • Home
  • ISSUES
    • Understanding the issues
    • Autonomy v Public Safety
    • Pressure and Coercion
    • Disability Concerns
    • Poverty Issues
    • Impact on the NHS
    • Palliative Care
    • Public Polling
    • Slippery Slope
    • Vague Definitions
    • Means of Death
    • Anorexia & Depression
    • Unsolved Problems
    • Suicide Prevention
    • Alternative Approach
  • Latest
  • Quotes
  • Contact
  • Join the Campaign
Join the Campaign

Means of Death

Key Points

Read Next :

  • Unsolved Problems

Death by lethal drugs may not be peaceful, painless or quick

The lethal drugs administered under ‘assisted dying’ schemes are often the same ones used to execute prisoners on death row in the USA.​

Professor Joel Zivot of Emory university has written that when assisted suicide deaths use the same form of lethal drugs given as part of American death penalty protocols people can die from drowning in their own secretions as fluid collects in the lungs (what doctors call a pulmonary oedema).

"Feeling like you're drowning in your own body - where's the dignity in that death?"

Michelle Anna Moffat post to X

Sometimes the drugs do not work and the person does not die.

Sometimes the drugs cause distressing side effects before the person dies.

The bitter taste of the drug cocktails means people can experience difficulty swallowing drugs, vomiting, seizures and even regaining consciousness (after ingesting the drugs).

And sometimes it can take a long time for the person to die.

Nearly 7% of people take more than 6 hours.
In one Oregon case, it took 137 hours – more than 5½ days

The Denver Post described the 2017 assisted suicide death of a Colorado man diagnosed with cancer, which took over 9 hours, like this:​

“On the day of Kurt’s death, Susan [his wife] mixed the liquids prescribed as directed and Kurt began drinking the compound. ‘But with every sip,’ Susan says, ‘he’s choking and coughing, choking and coughing.’ It went on for nearly 20 minutes…
Although he never regained consciousness, the gasping, uneven breathing continued. Two hours passed. Then 4 hours. ‘At 4:15,’ Susan says, ‘I started to majorly panic’’.As she tried without success to reach a doctor, a couple more disturbing thoughts crossed her mind: She feared that Kurt, despite his unconsciousness, could hear everything — the calls, the desperation in her voice. And she wondered if his choking when he first took the medication meant that he had aspirated enough to delay its effect.
Around 7 pm, she asked the hospice to send a nurse. Shortly after the nurse arrived, a doctor called and suggested some additional measures. Soon after, Susan saw her husband sit up slightly and appear to retch three times. She ran to his bedside. Then he slid back into his pillows and stopped breathing.

Read Next :

  • Unsolved Problems

Promoting Care, Opposing Euthanasia

Care Not Killing was set up in 2006 as an alliance of individuals and organisations which brings together disability and human rights groups, healthcare providers, and faith-based bodies, with the aims of promoting more and better palliative care; ensuring that existing laws against euthanasia and assisted suicide are not weakened or repealed; and helping the public to understand the consequences of any further weakening of the law.

Get in touch

Care Not Killing Scotland
6 Marshalsea Road
London   SE1 1HL

Media enquiries:

Please contact Tom Hamilton Communications on  07836 603977

Connect with us

Facebook Twitter Youtube

Contact us

Message us via this site

  • Home
  • ISSUES
  • Alternative Approach
  • Latest
  • Quotes
  • Contact
  • Join the Campaign
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Home
  • ISSUES
  • Alternative Approach
  • Latest
  • Quotes
  • Contact
  • Join the Campaign
  • Privacy
  • Cookies

Care Not Killing Scotland is a trading name of CNK Alliance Limited, a Limited Company in England and Wales, Company No. 06360578

© CARE NOT KILLING SCOTLAND - All rights reserved

website by RAMPANT LION MEDIA